Year Seven

DC Capitol Police[This was originally posted in 2008 on my LiveJournal]

For all the posturing and pontificating of the politicians in charge of things, you’d think the world was an infinitely safer place (thought not quite yet safe enough for us to actually feel safe, mind you–still have to keep spending all that money and adding new measures for our own safety, y’know).

The simple fact is: it isn’t.

If anything, we’re in more actual danger now than we were before. As economic times get tough–as that belt tightens and the challenge of putting food on the table spreads to more and more citizens who were used to being pretty OK gets added to all the other stresses of modern life–friction among the classes heats up. Add to that the still increasing rhetoric about unseen enemies and how our own political parties (whichever one the speaker isn’t part of) are just out for themselves and looking to screw you over and we’re potentially in a powder keg playing with matches.

Yes, I’m negative and cynical on this point. And days like today–especially during weeks like this week (where not only am I stressed out by work but also had to walk through a swarm of cops, some with automatic weapons, on my way to work yesterday)–bring that out in spades.

September 11, 2001… I was a reporter when it happened… it and what followed most certainly didn’t change most things for the better.

It’s an ongoing thing. (Read what I’ve written in years past with that link… I’ll come up with something more coherent when I’m done with work.)

Six Years

War [Without End] on Terror[This was originally posted in 2007 on my LiveJournal]

I’ve said it all before.

In summation, we have been destroying ourselves.

No one needs to attack us again. We have done and continue to do more damage to what I consider the heart and soul of the American Ideal, the grand dream this country represented for a very long time.

Our leaders continue to disrespect the memories and destroyed lives of the more than 6,000 people who have passed on our side of the conflict (those in the initial attacks and those who have died on the actual battlefield).

Our blindly “patriotic” and scared countrymen are blind to the forces that influence them.

Our “bold and outspoken” representatives on the other side of the argument continue to be ineffective and dull.

Our “enemy” continues to be poorly defined and, in my opinion, exaggerated to nonsensical levels.

We have been destroying ourselves.

Infinitely more effective for our real enemies. They need do nothing but sit, watch and then come in to sweep up the shattered, withering pieces.

Five Years In

ACLU Patriot Act Poster[This was originally posted in 2006 on my LiveJournal]

I’ve spent the last two days more or less avoiding the normal network channels and all the specials they’re running. Tonight, I finally gave in and kept the TV on to watch what our Commander in Chief had to say about this anniversary. Partially, I did it to see how he would (again) twist the tragedy to his agenda. Mostly I did it so I wouldn’t miss the beginning of the show that came on after it.

Five years ago I was working for a local weekly paper in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains. Just under two hours from the heart of New York City. Our office was in a location with bad radio reception and we had no cable TV running to the building at that point. With all the major news website unavailable, I got most of my information that day from cNET.com and from people running from our office to a nearby home to watch stuff on CNN.

It wasn’t until many hours after the fact that I saw the first video of the towers collapsing. By then, the initial shock had worn off and I had accepted the tragedy. It was terrible, but it was just pictures on a screen. A record of something that had happened and couldn’t be changed.

A lot of people didn’t reach that point for a very long time. Many people, it seems, still have not reached that point of acceptance of the past as immutable.

And many of those currently in power seem to be more than happy to capitalize on that still open wound.

In the months that followed that mid-September Tuesday morning massive government action was taken. Plans and program were put in motion–some of which we are just learning about officially now–that would quickly change the face of the government. Plans and programs that would not only cut deeply into the freedoms guarantied by our Constitution, but would do so in the name of safety and security.

All the while talking heads squawked on about how we were living in a new world and how things would never be the same. How we weren’t safe anymore and how we were never really safe. The public ate it up. The media ate it up, spit it back out and ate it up again.

We entered a war. Our military might crossed the border into Afghanistan, hot on the trail of Al Queda, the organization responsible for (or at least the one that had taken responsibility for) the attacks. We made quick work of dismantling an oppressive government we had put in place decades earlier when we were fighting another foe. The leaders still eluded us–and the “big one” still does today–and the organization splintered and went underground.

We entered another war. This one build on misinformation, disinformation, outright lies and an often implied (and sometimes out right said) connection to those grandly horrible attacks against our cities. Our war machines, still warm from the Afghan deserts, rolled to Iraq and toppled another oppressive regime–not one we had put in place, but one we had been content enough to allow to commit near genocide in the past. We declared “mission accomplished” and have since seen more death and destruction than during the actual war.

Our President uses The War on Terror to justify secret surveillance operations, secret prisons, blatant violations of Constitutional law and “expedited” legal proceedings. He has standing proudly behind him a cadre of supporters in both the military and commercial complexes (we were warned of this by President Eisenhower). His speechwriters and spin men are the best in the business and, especially in the early days of panic and fear, manipulated public opinion with a Machiavellian skill that quickly turned our government process more opaque than it has ever been before.

Today, five years in, the public opinion of this country’s oppressive regime is eroding. Still, there are strong and powerful forces supporting the work it does–the work against the basic tenets of this country. In the name of Nationalism and under the banner of “Our Own Good” the powers that be have continued to slice away at the checks and balances that have kept the governed safe from the government. We are starting to wise up–to speak out as an appalled whole–but we are coming together late in the game.

We must all rally against that which is definitely not in our best interest. We are an intelligent and educated population (though, it seems, less so now than we were a half-decade ago). We must demand a return of transparency to our government. We must require the balances to be set back in place to prevent us from having a king.

It may not yet be too late to fix what we have let become broken.

It may not yet be too late to truly honor those who died in fire, steel and concrete five years ago.

For that is what we should do–honor them. Honor their unwilling and unsuspecting sacrifice. They died so others could make a statement. A statement We The People chose to respond to in a way that fundamentally changed our nation.

Vengeance is a hollow victory that consumes more than it saves. And that, at best, is what we have been pursuing. At worst, we have all been played for fools by power hungry individuals and shadowy groups that seek to maintain and increase their holdings at any cost. The Truth–for all it matters–lies somewhere between.

I have no greater fear of terrorism than I did six years ago. What I fear now–and what I have come to fear more and more each year for the past five–is my own government. I fear that my speech will label me an enemy of the State. I fear that in the heat of a panic I will become an accidental target of my own protectors. I fear that I will not be able to recognize my own country in another five years.

I fear that we have not opened our eyes soon enough to realize how much we have given up.

September 11, 2001 – From where I was

CNN Screenshot of 9/11 breaking news

[This was originally written back in 2004 over on my LiveJournal.]

Back in 2001 I was working for a local weekly paper in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains (about 2 hours north and west of New York City). Our production cycle ended on Wednesday, when the paper had to be out the door by 9 a.m. in order to get to the printer on time and get on the stands by Thursday morning. That made Tuesday our major production day. If all was running smoothly, at least half the paper would be done by the time we left Monday night, giving us time to put the news in and proofread all day Tuesday.

Tuesday, 11 September, started out like any normal Tuesday would. I was running late from staying up too late Monday night (after leaving work too late, as usual). My drive to the office was twenty minutes, all back roads, and I took great pleasure in listening to the morning show on the local classic rock station. Like all morning shows, there was always a bunch of joking going on, usually at the expense of local news or members of the morning crew.

Just as I pulled into the parking lot, the morning show was coming back from a commercial and the lead guy asked the other members of the crew if they had heard anything about a plane hitting the World Trade Center in NYC. They laughed and he said “No, really… I just heard that a small plane hit the World Trade Center.” The laughing stopped a little and I turned the car off and went into the office.

“Did anyone here hear anything about a plane hitting the World Trade Center?” I asked when I came in the door.

Of course, no one had. There was no regular radio reception in the office and no TV reception either. So I began trying to find out what was going on.

The web, of course, was the first place I went to. By the time my computer booted up, most of the major news sites had already begun to go down due to heavy traffic. It wasn’t until I got to CNet.com that I found confirmation of something going on.

That’s when the office suddenly snapped into “real newspaper” mode. We sent people out to a former employee’s place down the street to see what was on TV. They called back in with reports of what CNN was showing (images we know all too well now). Our news editor called out to local officials and emergency workers to get what information he could from them.

By the time the towers fell, we had as much info as CNN did and were starting a list of people we knew who were down in the city. On that list was a columnist who lived not too far away from the WTC. We couldn’t get through to her.

News that the towers collapsed stopped us in our tracks. We all knew people that may have been down in the Ground Zero area when the cloud of debris pushed through the streets like a gray-brown tidal wave.

We pushed through. Because that’s all we could do. We had a job to do.

In that one day, we ripped apart our newspaper no fewer than three times. Late in the afternoon, we got in touch with our columnist who was able to give us a first-hand account of what had gone on. No other paper in our coverage area had that kind of coverage until two days later (which, unfortunately, was when ours hit the stands). The news pages were still being worked on Wednesday morning.

In the days and weeks that followed, we did what every other news organization in the country did–we followed the stories of those who had survived and those who had not. Rescue workers from our area made the trek down to the city to help in the search for survivors, local businesses donated ATVs and supplies. Families mourned the loss of loved ones or waited hopefully for good news.

One family lost a son who worked in the towers. His mother had been working at the WTC when it was first attacked in 1996. She had made her way out through a smoke filled stairwell, shaken but safe. Shortly thereafter, she picked up and moved the family to my area. News of her son’s death hit the family hard, even harder was not having a body to bury.

That one dark day in September has now cost us more than anyone could have imagined.

We’ve lost our sense of security. Our sense of isolation from the insanity of the rest of the world.

No, we weren’t untouched by acts of terror before September 11, 2001, but none had ever been seen by so many at once–all in real time thanks to the wonders of modern technology.

Now, three years later, we still feel the repercussions of those two exploding planes in New York City (and the other two, one in a Pennsylvania field, one, not too far from where I am now, at the Pentagon).

Now, three years later, the president who was just settling in to office when tragedy struck is seeking re-election.

Now we have serious decisions to make.

In the haste to have some sort of response, some sort of sense of security and safety, we allowed our leaders to do a lot of things. The Patriot Act was put in place. We started a war on two fronts, one in Afghanistan and then another (more dubious) one later in Iraq. We created a whole new department of the Federal Government.

People have been locked up, captured, killed and promoted, all in the name of safety and security.

Now we have to decide if it was all worth it.

Are we safer now then we were three years before September 11, 2001? Is it possible for us to ever feel safe again? How much are we willing to give up as we try?

Opinions abound, and I’m not going to get into them here and now.

No. Instead, I’ll just stop and remember that three years ago a terrible act, unimaginable to most, took the lives of thousands of my fellow Americans. Those people, and all the victims of terrorist actions on a grand scale, deserve to be remembered with respect.

Though they didn’t know it, they gave their lives for this country. Just by living and dying in an otherwise normal day in September, they have given us all much to think about.

And even more to work for.